Due to the nature of this blog and all, I feel I should note that the below represents only my feelings, not those of the ministry or the larger Church. Fasting is just something I struggle with as an individual, and as such there is a fair amount of disagreement between my feelings on the subject and, say, Brian’s. Not like we fight or anything, we just disagree. April understands fasting better than I do–she just gets it–and I suspect it will be a subject that I struggle to understand for the rest of my life.
————
The men’s small group decided to fast one day this week so we could talk about it on Monday evening at our weekly meeting. We were hoping that everyone would get something out of it or, if they haven’t done it before, maybe just learn what the experience is like… personally, I’ve fasted at times in the past, but it’s not an aspect of Christianity I’ve ever come to truly understand. I can see fasting if there’s something dire happening, or where you really want to draw closer to God. If you’re mourning, and/or really need to devote yourself in prayer… But just saying, "Hrm, I think I’ll fast on Saturday!" just for kicks, I’ve never really gotten that.
Still, that’s what I did. I read a couple of shorter books of the Bible this morning, spent the entire day in the apartment doing not much of anything (in order to conserve energy; I figured if I really went and did anything, I’d get really hungry), and finished the afternoon reading Ecclesiastes and napping on the couch. I hadn’t planning on falling asleep, but I hadn’t eaten in 22 hours and, well, it was comfy.
I had some weird, stream-of-consciousness dreams, and for a while thought I was awake but still thinking coherently. In retrospect, I’m fairly certain I wasn’t, but when I awoke two hours later, I had a sense of peace I hadn’t had before. My thoughts had centered around justifications for fasting. Why were we doing it? Why do we do it at all? And though I’m still not sure on the answer to these questions, I found an answer for myself, for this time.
I went into this gig thinking that, maybe by fasting I would learn why we fast. Maybe some spark of revelation would hit me at the end of the experience and illuminate, "Oh, that’s why we should fast!" When I awoke, though, the book of Ecclesiates continued to ring on my ears. "Meaningless, meaningless!" the teacher cries, "Everything is meaningless, simply chasing after the wind!"
If I want to learn something from God, I should simply ask Him. Sit down and study. Pray. I was chasing after the wind, thinking that if I experienced something, I might understand the theological importance behind it, but that doesn’t really work for me. And on a very real level, I don’t need to chase after God. It’d be like a cat chasing a string tied to a fan blade. It’s all around, and if I can just bring myself to step back and look, instead of leaping in and all over the place in a frenzy, I might come to understand what’s going on and why. God’s right here, so what can I gain by running all over the place for him? Will I find God better in Jerusalem than in Springfield? No. And just the same, I will not find him any better while fasting than while nourished.
I appreciate some of the aspects of the ritual, but for me, I have trouble with doing it just randomly, any old day. It’s the same for communion for me; there has to be a certain amount of ritual surrounding the experience for it to carry the correct gravitas for me. I would be better off eating and drinking, taking life as it comes, and spending time with God like I do every day, than trying to manufacture an experience. It’s like thinking, "Maybe if I just work a little harder, I’ll understand." The writer of Ecclesiastes assures us this is not the case, however, admonishing that all knowledge and wisdom belongs to God. As it is written in Chapter 2 (from the Message paraphrase):
And then I took a hard look at what’s smart and what’s stupid. What’s left to do after you’ve been king? That’s a hard act to follow. You just do what you can, and that’s it. But I did see that it’s better to be smart than stupid, just as light is better than darkness. Even so, though the smart ones see where they’re going and the stupid ones grope in the dark, they’re all the same in the end. One fate for all—and that’s it.
…
The best you can do with your life is have a good time and get by the best you can. The way I see it, that’s it—divine fate. Whether we feast or fast, it’s up to God. God may give wisdom and knowledge and joy to his favorites, but sinners are assigned a life of hard labor, and end up turning their wages over to God’s favorites. Nothing but smoke—and spitting into the wind.
In the cynical, skeptical writings of the Quester, as Eugene Peterson calls the author of Ecclesiastes, I began to truly understand that all Truth is God’s Truth. He decides whether to gift it to us or not; we can’t go out and take it for ourselves, not really. As such, we can’t earn it. I can’t fast enough to cajole God into teaching me something. The truth is that He has already offered me a place in His Kingdom. He called me to it before I was born, and Jesus died to assure it over two thousand years ago. God is going to teach me, and I am going to do my best to learn. Today, fasting, didn’t really bring that home for me. Reading the Bible and prayer napping did.
God gives me food, so I will eat. He has given me a good job, so I will work, and a nice home with a comfortable bed, so I will sleep indoors. He has given me discernment and knowledge and understanding that would boggle the mind of the pre-Christian me. He hasn’t given me a good understanding of or empathy for fasting, so I will continue to pursue a better understanding of that… I’m just not sure the random-fast is for me.